In the little book called the Problem of Pain, C.S. Lewis sums up the problem of human suffering in its simplest form. “If God were good, he would wish to make his creatures perfectly happy, and if God were almighty he would be able to do what he wished. But the creatures are not happy. Therefore God lacks either goodness, or power, or both.” This statement makes several assumptions, all of which may or may not even be correct in light of what the Bible says about God. However, we can all say with truth, that at some point every human being must experience suffering. I mean let’s face it; a person causes pain by simply being born. All of us suffer pain at one time in our lives, either from sickness, headaches, broken bones, cuts and scrapes, or even muscle and joint pain.
Now, while it is true that everyone suffers at some point in their lives, both Christians and nonchristians, it is not true that all suffering is the same. Looking at it from the outside, a Christian suffering from an incurable disease and a non-Christian suffering from the same disease may be said to be going through the same experience. But, according to the plain teachings of the Word of God, the two are not equal. From God’s point of view the non-Christian is suffering without purpose. Or, which may sometimes be the case, he is suffering at the due to the work of Satan, who is merely doing as he pleases with a member of his own kingdom. In the case of the Christian, an all-wise heavenly Father is permitting suffering in a carefully controlled situation in order that he might accomplish a desirable purpose. The Book of Job alone teaches us about God’s purpose in suffering.
However, if suffering that is endured by the Christian has a purpose, then surely we are not out of line by asking the question, “What is the purpose of this suffering?” If we are to learn from suffering, then we must ask what it is that we are to learn. If we are profit from it, as the Bible teaches, then we must ask how. The answers to these questions and more can be found in various places in the Word of God, but this morning we are going to look at a passage in John chapter 9, where the evangelist tells us about Jesus’ interaction with a man born blind.
We are only going to read a few verses this morning, John 9:1-5. Let’s read them now. As he passed by, he saw a man blind from birth. 2 And his disciples asked him, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?” 3 Jesus answered, “It was not that this man sinned, or his parents, but that the works of God might be displayed in him. 4 We must work the works of him who sent me while it is day; night is coming, when no one can work. 5 As long as I am in the world, I am the light of the world.”
As Jesus and his disciples pass by, Jesus sees a man who was blind from birth. His disciples as him the age old question, the question we always ask. But their question betrays some of their underlying false assumptions that Jesus immediately corrects.
The first wrong assumption is that his condition was caused by something he or his parents did. This man or his parents did something wrong, and his condition was the result of some sort of cosmic retribution. This is also called karma, derived from the eastern religion of Hinduism. We have all heard this at some point or another. Someone wrongs someone else or do something bad, and people will say that karma will get him. Or this will come back to bite him. Something happens to this person, and people say it was karma that got him back. All of these assume that people who do bad things will have retribution come back on them. This is a false assumption, from a false religion, and is simply paganism. Suffering in this life is often attributed to doing something wrong in this life or a previous life. Again, this is paganism, and is rampant in the belief system of so many people today. The Scriptures do not support this.
The other assumption is that this man’s parents sinned and caused his condition. Now, the Bible does consider this a possibility. Sins of parents can be visited upon their children. Drug or alcohol abuse during pregnancy can cause birth defects. Abusive parents can cause pain and suffering in children, sometimes for life. But Jesus says something about this reason here.
Another error is that people believe that God is a stern, mean judge who is constantly watching us and ready to pounce when we mess up. God is looking down from the heavens and spends his time watching us waiting for us to mess up. And when we do, BAM! He brings the hammer down on us. This is not only not true, but also a major slam on the character of God. In fact, it is God who keeps us from being as bad as we can be. Yes God will judge, and sometimes we reap the consequences of our sins. But God is patient, kind, and loving. Those who do not know the Bible have these false views of God. That is why we do what we do here. My desire for all of you is to have you know truly the one true living God. What he is like, and what he not like. So we may all worship him in spirit and in truth.
Another error of the disciples in their question is that they condemn this man and his parents as a judge themselves without thought of God and his great grace and forgiveness. Think about this. When something bad happens to someone, and they are suffering, often times we ask ourselves, “What did he do to deserve this?” Perhaps we ask of ourselves, “What did I do to deserve this?” Those are the wrong questions to ask because they make you out to be a judge instead of God. We assume things about someone’s circumstances and that they must have done something to deserve what they are getting, even if not in a vengeful way. But we still make ourselves out to be judge. Suffering may arise out of sin, but God afflicts his people and others for various reasons. Some people’s sins God does not punish in this world, but whose punishment he delays for the future life. Sometimes God inflicts trials on his most faithful, not because they sinned more, but because they can taught to kill their sin even more, and grow in faith and knowledge all the more. So be careful when looking at someone who is suffering and imagining the reasons for it.
This is a lesson for us today. There are no pat or simple answers for human suffering. There are answers of course, and we will discuss one of them momentarily. There are no just simplistic answers. Consequently, we cannot say, as many people do today, that it is the right of every believer to be healthy. This is nonsense. Or that suffering is always the direct result of personal sin. In some cases, suffering is corrective. It is given in order to get us back on the path that God has chosen for us. In other cases, it is constructive. It is given to build character. In still other cases, as here, it is given solely that God might receive glory.
First of all, suffering can be corrective. God sends some pain in order to get us back on the path he has set before us. As parents, how often do we correct our children with spankings, or grounding, or even depriving them of their computer or phone? Do parents do this because they delight in seeing their children suffer? Or do they do these things because they don’t love their children? Of course not. The opposite is true. We correct those we love because we don’t want them to get hurt, or mess up their life, or hurt others. The same is true of God. Look at Hebrews 12 starting with verse 5: My son, do not regard lightly the discipline of the Lord, nor be weary when reproved by him. 6 For the Lord disciplines the one he loves, and chastises every son whom he receives.” 7 It is for discipline that you have to endure. God is treating you as sons. For what son is there whom his father does not discipline? 8 If you are left without discipline, in which all have participated, then you are illegitimate children and not sons. 9 Besides this, we have had earthly fathers who disciplined us and we respected them. Shall we not much more be subject to the Father of spirits and live?
The first thing we should do when we are confronted with suffering is to ask God whether or not it is intended for our correction. If it is, then we need to confess our sin or our straying from the ways of God and return once more to the path set before us.
Secondly, God sends the believer some sufferings that are constructive. This is where God sends some suffering into our lives in order to build us up and grow us in Christ. There is an old, silly, saying in the Army. Pain is weakness leaving the body. This is funny, but it is also true. After I came home from the hospital, I could barely walk to the end of my driveway. Now my wife and I walk two miles or more sometimes every day. It hurt. I am sore, even now. But this pain reminds me that I am getting stronger every day. The same is true with some affliction that God send our way. It hurts. But we also grow because of it and through it to become better people and stronger followers of Christ. David in Psalm 119:67 writes, Before I was afflicted I went astray, but now I keep your word.
Finally, we get to our text this morning. Jesus gives us an answer to the problem of human suffering in verse 3 of our text. Jesus answered, “It was not that this man sinned, or his parents, but that the works of God might be displayed in him. As in the case of the man who had been born blind, some suffering is merely that the grace of God might be revealed in the life of the Christian. This man had been born blind, so that when Jesus was born and when he would pass by him as the sovereign God had ordained, Jesus would heal him, in a way that many people would see. Including the Pharisees. Some would come to believe. Others would have their hearts hardened, like Pharaoh in Egypt, or like the Pharisees here. We will talk about this next week.
Would God permit a man to be struck with total blindness throughout the better part of his life so that in God’s own time he might become the object of a miracle performed by the Lord Jesus Christ? Look at the case of Lazarus. Would God permit a child of his to die, bringing suffering not only upon himself but also upon his sisters who mourned for him, just so God could be glorified? In the light of the Word of God we answer not only that God would do such things but that he has done them and, actually, continues to do them in order that he might bring victory for himself and all believers in the great and invisible war between the powers of good and of evil. Those who know God well know this and, in part, understand it. They know that God is both perfect and loving and that he does all things well.
So let me conclude with a question this morning. When you or others undergo pain and suffering, do you blame God and get angry at him? Do you think that someone suffers because it is retribution for something bad that person has done? Karma? Or do you seek God and pray for understanding. Do you seek God because it may be a corrective to get you back on track, back on the path God has set for you? Do you also seek spiritual wisdom and understanding because it just me be constructive? It may be God’s way of building you up, strengthening you so that you grow all the more in the grace and knowledge of Jesus Christ. Or it may be that God allows you to suffer or for Satan to torment you so that in your suffering, you demonstrate the grace and glory of God in your life. In any of these, we must constantly seek the Lord, and His own wisdom, strength, and understanding, so that we may use this suffering to accomplish God’s will.